QB Succession Plans: Learning From Cousins

𝕵𝖊𝖙𝖎𝖒𝖔𝖇 𝕯𝖎𝖌𝖎𝖙𝖆𝖑 𝕸𝖊𝖉𝖎𝖆

You need 5 min read

·

Post on Dec 22, 2024

42 visitor like this post

Share

QB Succession Plans: Learning From Cousins

The quarterback position is the most crucial in football, a fact underscored by the constant scrutiny surrounding its incumbents and the often-fraught transitions between them. Finding a successful succession plan is a perpetual challenge for NFL franchises, and studying past examples, both successful and unsuccessful, is crucial for building a sustainable winning formula. The recent history of the Minnesota Vikings and the Philadelphia Eagles, and their handling (or mishandling) of the Cousins-Wentz succession, offers valuable lessons for teams navigating this complex landscape.

The Cousins Conundrum: A Case Study in Patience and Pragmatism

Kirk Cousins’ career trajectory provides a fascinating case study. Drafted in the fourth round by the Washington Redskins, he wasn't an immediate star. Instead, he patiently waited his turn, learning the ropes behind established quarterbacks, before finally seizing his opportunity. This period of development, often overlooked, is a critical element in any successful quarterback succession plan. The Redskins, while ultimately choosing to let him walk in free agency, recognized his potential and provided a structured environment for his growth. This wasn't a smooth process; there were ups and downs, but the organization demonstrated a commitment to fostering his development rather than rushing him into a starting role unprepared.

The Vikings, on the other hand, took a different approach. They signed Cousins to a lucrative contract, effectively bypassing the developmental phase and placing immediate pressure on him to perform. While Cousins has been a consistently productive passer for the Vikings, delivering respectable statistics, the team hasn't achieved the ultimate goal: a Super Bowl victory. This highlights a key takeaway: while immediate results are tempting, a long-term perspective, incorporating a systematic development strategy for the next quarterback, is crucial.

Lessons Learned from the Cousins Era:

• Patience is key: Rushing a quarterback into a starting role before they're ready can be detrimental to both the player's development and the team's success.
• Structured development: A clear plan for mentorship, practice reps, and game experience is essential for maximizing a quarterback's potential.
• Realistic expectations: Evaluating a quarterback's performance should consider their stage of development and the surrounding circumstances. Consistent statistical production isn't always indicative of success, particularly when considering team context.

The Wentz Experiment: A Cautionary Tale of Impatience

Carson Wentz's journey represents a stark contrast. The Eagles, buoyed by his early success, appeared to have found their franchise quarterback. However, the subsequent decision to draft Jalen Hurts, while ostensibly adding competition, signaled a lack of unwavering faith in Wentz's long-term prospects. This created an atmosphere of uncertainty and arguably undermined Wentz's confidence, impacting his performance. The ensuing trade to the Colts further underscored the Eagles’ wavering belief in their initial choice.

While the Eagles eventually found success with Jalen Hurts, the transition was far from seamless. The team experienced periods of instability and inconsistency, highlighting the potential pitfalls of prematurely abandoning a quarterback, even one experiencing difficulties. This impulsive decision overlooked the importance of providing a robust support system and adjusting the scheme to maximize a player's strengths.

The Wentz Experience Teaches Us:

• Avoid premature abandonment: Sticking with a quarterback through challenges, provided there’s a reasonable expectation of improvement, can yield significant long-term benefits.
• Comprehensive support system: A strong coaching staff, capable offensive line, and a supportive environment are essential for quarterback development and sustained success.
• Strategic scheme adjustments: Tailoring the offensive scheme to a quarterback’s strengths can significantly improve their performance and increase their chances of success.

Building a Sustainable Succession Plan: Combining the Best Practices

The experiences of both Cousins and Wentz offer valuable insights for building effective QB succession plans. A successful strategy requires a blend of patience, a strategic approach to development, and a willingness to adapt to circumstances. Here's a blueprint based on these lessons:

1. Identify Potential Early:

Scout and draft quarterbacks with high potential, even if they aren't immediate starters. Investing in talented players early allows for a longer period of development and reduces the pressure to find a replacement quickly.

2. Structured Development Program:

Implement a comprehensive development program that includes mentorship from experienced quarterbacks, specialized coaching, and tailored practice regimens. This allows quarterbacks to hone their skills and gradually adapt to the demands of the NFL.

3. Provide Consistent Support:

Surround young quarterbacks with a strong supporting cast, including a reliable offensive line, talented receivers, and a competent coaching staff. A stable environment reduces the burden on the quarterback and maximizes their chances of success.

4. Evaluate with Nuance:

Avoid snap judgments based on short-term performances. Assess quarterback development holistically, considering factors such as game experience, individual improvement, and the context of the team’s performance.

5. Adapt and Adjust:

Be willing to adapt the offensive scheme to a quarterback's strengths and weaknesses. Flexibility allows quarterbacks to thrive and increases the likelihood of team success.

6. Consider the Draft and Free Agency:

Having a clear succession plan doesn't exclude leveraging the NFL draft or free agency. If your chosen developmental player is underperforming or doesn’t progress as hoped, having a backup plan ready is crucial, though this must be implemented carefully to avoid sending mixed signals to the incumbent.

Conclusion: A Long-Term Vision for Success

Successfully managing quarterback transitions is a complex endeavor demanding patience, a holistic approach to player development, and a willingness to adapt. Learning from the past, including the experiences of Kirk Cousins and Carson Wentz, is crucial for building a sustainable and effective quarterback succession plan. By prioritizing long-term vision, teams can significantly increase their chances of sustained success in the highly competitive world of professional football. The key takeaway is to avoid knee-jerk reactions and embrace a calculated, long-term strategy that places a strong emphasis on player development and supports their growth over short-term gains. This strategic approach, fueled by both patience and adaptability, will maximize a team’s chances of future prosperity.